The relationship between science and psychoanalysis has often been tense and critical. Andr Haynal explores this dynamic by addressing three key questions: how is psychoanalytic "knowledge" established? What methodology and epistemology underpin psychoanalytic theory? What historical circumstances have influenced the development of psychoanalysis? Haynal's familiarity with the breadth of analytic thought allows him to begin with a systematic discussion of analytic theory. The second part delves into historical topics, focusing on Freud and his interactions with his followers. Notably, a chapter dedicated to Freud and his "favorite disciple," Sandor Ferenczi, provides an engaging exploration of their complex intellectual and personal bond. Through this examination, Haynal sheds light on the evolution of psychoanalytic thought and its ongoing tension with scientific principles.
