The Matter of Facts

More about the book

Modern science relies on experimental evidence, yet scientists often selectively choose what evidence to use and frequently disagree on its interpretation. In this exploration, the authors examine how evidence is produced and utilized in science, highlighting significant issues that challenge its reliability, such as inappropriate statistical tests, a lack of replication studies, and biases in publishing and citing "positive" results. To address these concerns, they emphasize the need to understand the mechanisms that make science effective and the pitfalls that can lead it astray. Contrary to the myth that scientists continually challenge their thinking, the reality is that they often seek to persuade others of their ideas, blending reason with rhetoric. This can lead to a focus on supportive evidence while overlooking contradictory data. Through a series of essays on controversies, disputes, and discoveries, the authors illustrate science as a human endeavor driven by both passion and reason. By examining the fluidity of scientific concepts and the unpredictable nature of scientific development, they provide insight into the current state of modern science and the challenges it faces.